
The short answer
The problem with most supplement advice
Supplement guides tend to describe everything in the same even voice, so creatine, which has been studied for decades, reads the same as glutamine, which has been tested and found to do nothing for healthy lifters. They also skip the doses, which is strange, because for the two that work the dose is the advice. Knowing caffeine helps is useless if you do not know how much.
Here is the short version, and then the detail behind each row.
| Supplement | What it does | How much |
|---|---|---|
| Creatine | More work in hard, repeated efforts | 3 to 5 g a day, any time |
| Caffeine | Strength, endurance, power, output | 3 to 6 mg per kg, about 60 min before |
| Protein powder | Convenience, not an effect of its own | Only what your daily total is missing |
| Glutamine | No muscle gain, may ease soreness | 0.3 g per kg, only for soreness |
| BCAAs | Far less than a whole protein does | Not worth buying |
Creatine
Creatine helps your muscles produce energy quickly, which matters most in short, hard, repeated efforts. Studies have consistently shown that supplementing raises the creatine stored in muscle, which helps explain the improved high intensity performance and the greater training adaptations that follow1.
Take 3 to 5 g a day. You do not need a loading phase, and timing does not matter much, so take it whenever you will remember. Expect a small increase on the scale in the first week or two, which is water held inside muscle rather than fat.
On safety, this is one of the few supplements with long term data. The position stand reports that short and long term use, up to 30 g a day for five years, is safe and well tolerated in healthy people and across a range of patient groups from infants to the elderly1.
Caffeine
Caffeine is the other one worth your money, and it does more than wake you up. Benefits show up across muscular endurance, movement velocity, muscular strength, sprinting, jumping and throwing, as well as a wide range of aerobic and anaerobic efforts2.
The dose is 3 to 6 mg per kilogram of body weight, about 60 minutes before you train. The minimum useful dose may be as low as 2 mg per kg2. For a 180 pound person, the 3 to 6 range works out at roughly 245 to 490 mg. A mug of brewed coffee is about 95 mg, which puts the low end at two or three cups.
That is a real dose, and it is why the vague advice to have a coffee before the gym often does nothing. It is also why the upper end is not for everyone. Responses vary a lot between people, and caffeine late in the day costs you sleep, which will undo more than the session gains you.
Protein powder is food, not a supplement
Powder has no special property. It is a convenient way to reach a protein target you were going to hit anyway, and it only helps if you were falling short. A meta-analysis of 49 studies found that protein supplementation did increase gains in strength and muscle during resistance training, but that intakes beyond about 1.6 g per kilogram a day produced no further gains in fat-free mass5.
So the question is not whether to buy powder. It is whether your daily total is already there. We cover how to work that out in how your body uses protein.
The two that are oversold
Glutamine
Guides often claim most people do not get enough glutamine from food. That claim does not survive testing. In a double blind trial, 31 young adults did six weeks of total body resistance training while taking either glutamine or a maltodextrin placebo. Both groups improved, and the authors concluded that glutamine supplementation had no significant effect on muscle performance, body composition or muscle protein breakdown3.
Recovery is a separate question, though, and there the answer is different. In a double blind crossover trial, 16 people took either glutamine at 0.3 g per kilogram a day or a placebo for 72 hours after deliberately damaging eccentric knee extensions. The glutamine condition produced faster return of peak torque, 91% against 86% of starting force at 72 hours, and lower soreness at 24, 48 and 72 hours6.
So the honest summary is narrower than the usual one in both directions. Glutamine will not build muscle or strength over a training block, and the claim that your food leaves you short is unfounded. But if your complaint is soreness after unaccustomed work, there is a real finding there, from a small study.
BCAAs
Branched-chain amino acids are three of the nine essential amino acids. To build muscle protein you need all nine, so supplying three leaves the other six to come from breaking down existing muscle. That caps the result: the theoretical ceiling for BCAAs alone is around a 30% rise in muscle protein synthesis, and realistically less4. Whole protein supplies the full set, which is why a scoop of whey or a meal beats a BCAA drink. We go into this in amino acids and protein quality.
The step nobody mentions: third party testing
Supplements are regulated far more loosely than medicines, and what is on the label is not guaranteed to be what is in the tub. Look for products certified by an independent testing organization. It costs a little more and it is the only part of buying supplements that protects you from a problem you cannot taste or see.
This matters most if you compete in a tested sport, where a contaminated product is your responsibility regardless of intent.
Put it into practice
Sources
All research- 1International Society of Sports Nutrition position stand: safety and efficacy of creatine supplementation in exercise, sport, and medicineKreider et al., 2017 (ISSN position stand). Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition 14:18.
- 2International society of sports nutrition position stand: caffeine and exercise performanceGuest et al., 2021 (ISSN position stand). Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition 18(1):1.
- 3Effect of glutamine supplementation combined with resistance training in young adultsCandow et al., 2001. European Journal of Applied Physiology 86(2):142-149.
- 4Branched-chain amino acids and muscle protein synthesis in humans: myth or reality?Wolfe, 2017. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition 14:30.
- 5A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of the effect of protein supplementation on resistance training-induced gains in muscle mass and strength in healthy adultsMorton et al., 2018. British Journal of Sports Medicine 52(6):376-384.
- 6The influence of oral L-glutamine supplementation on muscle strength recovery and soreness following unilateral knee extension eccentric exerciseLegault et al., 2015. International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism 25(5):417-426.
General fitness information, not medical advice. If you have an injury or a health condition, check with a professional before starting a new kind of training.